New York’s prettiest ice creams

Whether it’s Italian gelato, Japanese matcha ice cream, colourful towering cones, or vegan ice cream in New York that you crave - the city has it covered.

These New York City ice creams look good. So good that we’re sure most of them have been designed for Instagram.

But, you’ll be as pleased as us to find out that they taste great too! Just make sure it doesn't dribble down your hand while you're busy snapping.

Oddfellows

Oddfellows Ice Cream New York

Oddfellows Ice Cream New York

Considered the most delectable ice cream in NYC by locals, OddFellows makes small-batch ice cream from scratch in their Brooklyn kitchen. The base is pasteurized in-house, using the finest ingredients and hormone-free, additive-free, locally sourced dairy. Their method allows for fresh, high quality ice cream in regularly changing flavours, even throughout the day. If that weren’t enough, warm waffle cones are made fresh to order and topping options are plentiful. We’d recommend heading to their Williamsburg, Brooklyn flagship, where the deliciously creamy magic began.

Taiyaki

Taiyaki ice cream New York

Taiyaki ice cream New York

Taiyaki is the talk of the town and you can see why.  Their warm traditional Japanese fish waffles are adorably fun and overflowing with colourful soft serve. Go authentic with matcha and black sesame or opt for pastel pink ice cream topped with sprinkles and a unicorn horn if you’re if you’re looking for the utmost in Instagram #foodporn. In typical Japanese fashion it’s almost too cute to eat but you quickly realise you have to in order to avoid a meltdown. Top tip - plan your visit tactically as this unassuming shop front on the edge of the city’s Chinatown district is rarely without a queue.

Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream

Born in a retro buttery yellow truck, brothers Ben and Pete and Pete’s wife Laura set out to bring high quality ice cream to the streets of New York and Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream was born. Their Classic scoops are crafted with nothing more than fresh milk and cream, cane sugar, and egg yolks, while the increasingly popular vegan scoops are homemade cashew milk, organic coconut milk, organic extra virgin coconut oil, organic cane sugar, pure cocoa butter, and organic carob bean. Can’t decide which flavour to go for? The hipster yet chirpy staff treat you to generous tasting spoons - but if you want our advice, their creamy honeycomb is to die for.

Ice & Vice

Ice and Vice ice cream New York

Ice and Vice ice cream New York

Now this ice cream really was made for Instagram. If you’re looking for something extraordinary, try Ice & Vice, an experimental ice cream shop based in New York City. Don’t expect a plain of scoop of vanilla ‘round here. Famed for their unique flavours, we love that they keep their menu fresh and seasonal. Don’t expect to try the same flavour twice, unless of course you’re a regular. Their show stopper is 5 scoops tall with cookies between each flavour. Obviously our choice!

Davey’s Ice Cream

Davey’s Ice Cream Sandwich New York.

Davey’s Ice Cream Sandwich New York.

Davey's retro scoop shop situated in the East Village makes all desserts from scratch and pasteurises its own ice cream mix in-house. Whilst flavours and style influenced by the eccentric and artistic neighbourhood are tasty, it’s Davey’s ice cream cookie sandwiches that are the real crowd pleaser; made to order with two homemade cookies, a single scoop of ice cream and all the sprinkles.  

Ample Hills Creamery

Ice cream at Ample Hills is super fresh; handcrafted in small batches using local, all-natural milk, cream and eggs, produced by hormone-free, grass-fed, happy cows and chickens. What keeps the locals coming back for more? Whimsical flavours such as Snap Mallow Pop (our fave), a light texture and the vibrancy and spirit of their community.

Grom

Grom New York

Grom New York

Is it really a best ice creams list if it doesn't include Italian Gelato? New York was the first overseas Grom store to open, and you can find Grom in four locations across New York City. What makes Grom’s gelato so special? It’s made using the first-rate Italian ingredients, without artificial colouring and preservatives, and is whipped up to a creamy and authentic texture using traditional techniques. Sample their house special ‘Crema di Grom’ - a delicious combination of pastry cream, Ecuador “Arriba” chocolate chips and Grom’s own recipe meliga cookies. 

Love NYC? Find out more about the city in our Insider’s Travel Guide

New York, Statue of Liberty

New York, Statue of Liberty

Get lick-happy! Pin this article to your Pinterest page using this image, or share it via other social media handles below!

NORTH AMERICA, FOOD & DRINKContemporary Classthe best ice cream in new york, the best ice cream in nyc, the prettiest ice cream in new york, the prettiest ice cream in nyc, the most innstagrammable ice cream in new york, the most innstagrammable ice cream in nyc, vegan ice cream in new york, vegan ice cream in nyc, vegan ice cream, where to find vegan ice cream in new york, ice cream sandwich new york, non dairy ice cream new york, non dairy ice cream nyc, cashew milk ice cream new york, organic coconut milk ice cream new york, extra virgin coconut oil new york, organic carob bean ice cream new york, oddfellows ice cream new york, oddfellows ice cream nyc, Taiyaki ice cream new york, Taiyaki ice cream nyc, Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream new york, Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream nyc, Ice & Vice ice cream new york, Ice & Vice ice cream nyc, Davey's ice cream new york, Ample Hills Creamery new york, Wu Kong new york, Grom new york, Grom ice cream new york, Grom italian ice cream in new york, Grom gelato new york, Italian gelato in new york, Brooklyn ice cream, brooklyn new york ice cream, hormone free ice cream new york, additive free ice cream new york, Japanese fish waffle ice cream new york, match ice cream new york, match ice cream taiyaki, does taiyaki new york serve matcha ice cream, japanese ice cream, fish ice cream, fish shaped ice cream cone, fish cone ice cream, fish ice cream brooklyn, japanese taiyako, japanese taiyaki, retro ice cream vans, retro ice cream new york, honeycomb ice cream in new york, ice cream for instagram, experimental ice cream shop in new york, 5 scoop ice cream, best ice cream for instagram, best ice cream for instagram in new york, ice cream sandwich, davey's ice cream sandwich, Davey's ice cream cookie sandwich, ample hills, ample hills ice cream new york, ample hills ice cream nyc, Grom italian gelato, grom italian gelato new york, where is Grom gelato served in new york, Where is Grom ice cream served in new york, Oddfellows ice cream new york, Oddfellows ice cream, Taiyaki ice cream, Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream new york, Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream, Ice and vice ice cream new york, Ice and vice ice cream, Ice and vice ice cream instagram, Davey's ice cream new york USA, Ample Hills Creamery, Ample Hills Creamery ice cream, Ample Hills Creamery ice cream new york, New York, New York USA, USA, USA ice cream, New York ice cream, ice cream in new york, where to eat ice cream in new york, best ice creams in new york, prettiest ice creams in new york, best desserts in new york